Belvedere 21: Visibility Is Not Yet Power

With “Feminist Futures Forever,” Belvedere 21 returns to a history in which the institution itself has a stake. The decisive question extends beyond the exhibition: how does feminist art change a museum that has learned to honour it?

DOSSIERS

Hans Struberger

11/11/20267 min read

Belvedere 21 in Vienna, exterior view photographed on 9 August 2022. With “Feminist Futures Forever,” the museum returns to the history of the 1985 exhibition “Kunst mit Eigen-Sinn.” Photo: Leonhard Lenz, CC0 1.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

A museum can exhibit feminist art while leaving much of its own order intact. That possibility should concern us, especially when we consider the exhibition necessary. Recognition is a substantial achievement. It remains incomplete, however, when an institution uses the critical knowledge of art primarily to demonstrate its own openness. Those who spent decades fighting for visibility are entitled to more than a place in a persuasive institutional self-portrait.

At Belvedere 21, “Feminist Futures Forever” gives this question particular force. Curated by Christiane Erharter and Stefanie Reisinger, the exhibition brings together 238 international artistic positions and returns to “Kunst mit Eigen-Sinn,” held in 1985. The museum is thus engaging with a history that unfolded in the same building. It has a site from which to investigate what became of a public presence that had to be fought for. My position is clear: the significance of this undertaking depends on whether the earlier demand for participation now reaches the conditions under which the museum selects, collects and confers importance.

The title releases a peculiar tension. “Futures” keeps several possibilities open; “Forever” suggests a struggle that is never allowed to conclude.

This touches a problem within every triumphant history of emancipation. We can honour the pioneers, conserve their work and make their gestures familiar, while continually postponing the changes those works demand. Eventually, the enduring relevance of a claim also becomes evidence of how long its fulfilment has been deferred.

There is good reason, then, to pause at 1985. Initiated by VALIE EXPORT, “Kunst mit Eigen-Sinn” became possible after years of effort and with the political support of Johanna Dohnal. That prehistory belongs to the subject of art history. It reminds us that a public arena has to be made: through organisation, persuasion, funding and a willingness to sustain conflict. Exhibitions emerge under conditions that can subsequently disappear from their institutional memory. The photographs preserve the art; the negotiations that brought it there are much harder to retain.

This is where an intellectually demanding account of art history begins. In 1971, Linda Nochlin redirected the debate about the supposed absence of great women artists towards the institutions regulating education, professional opportunity and recognition. An uncomfortable consequence follows for the present. An expanded list of names can leave a narrow conception of greatness untouched. If we simply seek further exceptions who succeeded in rising through the system, we continue to tell a story about the triumph of the extraordinary individual. The conditions against which that ascent had to be achieved recede once again. I therefore consider it a mistake to treat feminist art history as a retrospective redistribution of fame. It changes the subject of inquiry itself. The time available for making a work, the ability to claim space, the division between paid employment and artistic labour, the question of who assumes everyday responsibilities: all belong to the conditions from which form emerges. They cannot explain a work completely. But to disregard them is to mistake the unequal distribution of artistic opportunity for a natural distribution of talent.

This certainly does not mean that a defensible political position guarantees a compelling work. Feminist criticism has particular reason to insist on precise aesthetic judgement. A work deserves attention for the way it organises perception, handles its material, opens contradictions and sustains difficult demands. Exclusion may help explain its genesis; its artistic force must articulate itself within the work. Treating women artists merely as evidence of a social injustice would be another way of depriving their practice of its independence.

VALIE EXPORT’s “Geburtenbett” of 1980 demonstrates the inadequacy of a purely thematic classification. In her account of the installation, the artist connects it with video imagery of Catholic transubstantiation and medical genetic manipulation. Religious and technological claims to authority enter a shared field. For me, the political precision of this constellation lies in the body’s emergence as the object of competing interpretative powers. Self-determination becomes legible through the procedures by which bodies are discussed, governed and made into objects of knowledge. Birth can scarcely be returned here to a reassuring symbol of life.

This also provides a standard for museum interpretation. An explanation can diminish a work when every disturbance is reliably resolved into a message known in advance. The audience then understands which side to take before encountering the art. The work becomes an impressive confirmation of an existing agreement. An exhibition with this ambition should demand more: it should clarify the political stakes while taking seriously the resistance a work offers to a seamless account of its meaning.

Ulrike Müller’s “Herstory Inventory: 100 Feminist Drawings by 100 Artists” is instructive in this respect. The collaborative project began with written descriptions of T-shirts held in Brooklyn’s Lesbian Herstory Archives, which participants translated into new drawings. What interests me is the redistribution of authorship. Between a garment once worn, its archival description and a subsequent visual response, a distance opens in which memory continues to work. Transmission becomes an activity involving several people. Each translation assumes responsibility for something it cannot entirely possess. This also changes how we read the museum’s figure of 238 positions: part of that multiplicity belongs to a work grounded in collaboration. Admiring the scale of participation alone may mean overlooking the crucial artistic operation. The individual sheet and the collective structure require attention simultaneously. For an institution whose inventories, labels and attributions of value frequently depend on distinguishable individual authors, this is a productive difficulty.

It should remain one. A project based on solidarity loses something when its principal outcome is to enlarge the reputation of a single organising personality.

The collaboration with Christiana Perschon on “Oral Herstory” addresses another part of the same history. Eighteen interviews preserve memories of 1985; the complete conversations are to remain publicly accessible at the Belvedere Research Center. I regard this as one of the undertaking’s most consequential decisions. Its protagonists are recognised as holders of knowledge that the institution does not already possess. Their recollections can illuminate their earlier work, but they can also correct the narratives on which an exhibition’s later reputation rests.

A witness’s voice is not a final authority. Memories may contradict one another, assign different weight to achievements or make former alliances appear different in retrospect. This is precisely why they deserve preservation. A living historical record must accommodate such discrepancies. A closed account offers certainty; an accessible conversation allows future researchers to ask different questions. Here, the museum accepts responsibility for a future whose interpretations it cannot control.

Making everyday life a spatial point of reference is similarly demanding. The exhibition addresses, among other subjects, work, public space, the bedroom and the bathroom; its architecture is by Dorit Margreiter Choy and Cosma Grosser. This creates an opportunity to investigate the apparently private conditions of public freedom. Who can close a door? Who has somewhere to withdraw? Who is watched, and who must remain available? Such questions acquire spatial forms long before they are articulated in a political programme.

The difficulty begins when an everyday space is assumed to constitute a universally shared experience. A bedroom may mean property, refuge, a workplace or danger. An exhibition that takes difference seriously has to keep these incompatibilities open. Otherwise, “intersectional” remains a benevolent adjective. The term acquires analytical force when it explains how different relations of power jointly produce a particular situation. That requires recalcitrant detail. A work must sometimes be allowed to disturb the context in which the curators have placed it.

At this point, the argument also reaches art criticism. A canonical museum has the authority to make heterogeneous works legible under a shared concept. We critics augment that authority when we adopt its vocabulary without examination. I explicitly support this exhibition’s political ambition. That is precisely why conceptual indulgence is out of place. Solidarity releases neither the museum nor its critic from the task of distinguishing a compelling connection from an asserted common ground.

Yet an exhibition can never settle that distinction through its spatial presentation alone. It has a duration, a dramaturgy and a limited share of public attention. A collection operates in another timescale. An acquired work creates obligations: it must be catalogued, conserved, lent, researched and shown again. Each of these activities creates further opportunities to understand it differently. This is why I attach considerable weight to the Belvedere’s documented expansion of its holdings of work by women artists. These acquisitions give its stated commitment a material duration.

Here, feminist museum policy becomes open to scrutiny. Which works receive space outside an explicitly feminist exhibition? Which change the account of a period? Which are interpreted alongside established canonical works, rather than continuing to appear exclusively within a history of exclusion? A temporary exhibition can concentrate attention. Subsequent collection practice helps determine whether that attention alters what art history comes to take for granted.

It would, however, be too convenient to suspect every instance of institutional recognition of appropriation. That would retrospectively declare the struggle for admission to the museum a mistake. Public collections can provide resources, protection and memory that are unavailable elsewhere. Those possibilities were also fought for. What matters is whether their use continues to admit conflict. An institution proves its worth by enabling research whose findings may change its own established account.

I locate the importance of “Feminist Futures Forever” in this connection between artistic transmission and institutional obligation. The archive, collaborative authorship and the collection offer concrete points from which to develop it. We need not attribute an accomplished transformation to the exhibition in order to take its ambition seriously. Nor is praise for its openness sufficient.

What we should demand is that the procedures through which art acquires lasting significance remain themselves open to change.

My judgement of what is at stake is unequivocal: the Belvedere must continue this history even when its continuation attracts less attention than its ceremonial return. Once the exhibition is dismantled, the unspectacular work begins, in responsibilities, acquisitions and future displays. That is where a political conviction demonstrates how much institutional weight it can bear. When the exhibition ends in March, feminist knowledge must not revert to being its historical subject. It must help decide what the museum does next.

Feminist Futures Forever
Belvedere 21, Arsenalstraße 1, 1030 Vienna
5 November 2026–8 March 2027
Curated by Christiane Erharter and Stefanie Reisinger
Exhibition architecture: Dorit Margreiter Choy and Cosma Grosser
belvedere.at

© 2024 All rights reserved.

Contact:

info@dokunstmag.de

Impressum

Angaben gemäß § 5 TMG:

Esteban Velazquez v. Wilhelm

Badergraben 16 04808 Wurzen

Kontakt:

Verantwortlich für den Inhalt nach § 18 Abs.2 MstV:

+49 15776999372

Esteban Velazquez v. Wilhelm

info@dokunstmag.de

www.dokunstmag.de

Badergraben 16 04808 Wurzen