THE ART JOURNAL FOR CONTEMPORARY CULTURE, ART HISTORY, AND THOUGHT
Rodin in Dresden: The Courage of the Unfinished Body
DIALOG
Rüdiger Steinhardt
11/4/20264 min read


Auguste Rodin, The Thinker, plaster, Staatliche Kunstsammlungen Dresden. Photograph: David Brandt, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
A small alabaster Thinker stood on my father’s bookshelf, barely twenty-five centimetres tall. Its place was on a handsome volume of the Divine Comedy. My father had brought the figure back from a trip to Paris in the late 1950s. As a child, I knew it as part of that domestic order in which certain objects occupy their places so naturally that their origins initially go unquestioned. Then, in the late 1980s, I saw a bronze version of Rodin’s Thinker in Paris. More than a change of material separated the small figure at home from that encounter. Something that had belonged to a familiar setting became perceptible as a work in its own right.
News of the Dresden exhibition “Das große Drama. Auguste Rodin und der Streit um die Moderne” brought both images back. What interests me now is precisely how readily Rodin has entered our understanding of art. A figure can become at home on a father’s bookshelf while the history of its artistic premises disappears. The Albertinum returns us to a moment when the recognition of such art still had to be negotiated.
Even the proximity to Dante’s book involved a connection I did not know as a child. Rodin developed The Thinker for his Gates of Hell, inspired by the Divine Comedy; the figure was originally conceived as the poet, Dante. This tells us nothing about my father’s intention. It tells us a great deal about a work’s migrations: a figure leaves a larger context, becomes independent, is reproduced and eventually turns into an apparently unambiguous symbol. The bent body is then made to stand for thought itself. Familiarity threatens to obscure its tension.
Here lies the exhibition’s opportunity. The celebrated name provides an entry into a collection whose history extends well beyond Rodin. The Albertinum presents approximately seventy sculptures alongside paintings, photographs, letters and other documents. Rodin appears with French and Belgian sculptors including Constantin Meunier, Albert Bartholomé and Alexandre Charpentier. Curated by Astrid Nielsen, the exhibition centres on a historical decision: Georg Treu opened Dresden’s sculpture collection to the international art of his own time.
In 1894, he acquired Rodin’s The Age of Bronze and Man with a Broken Nose. These were the first purchases of Rodin’s work for a German museum. Today, it is easy to applaud the decision as farsighted. At the time, it had to be made without the reassurance of an established canon. This is the intellectual challenge of a collecting policy: it must develop reasons for its choices before history has endorsed them.
The dispute intensified in 1901 around the acquisition of Bartholomé’s Monument aux morts. Dresden sculptors publicly opposed a purchasing policy that, in their view, favoured French art at the expense of local artists. This conflict deserves closer attention than the comfortable picture of an enlightened director confronting backward opponents. Public funds are limited. Asking who benefits from them is legitimate. That question does not, however, establish a right to aesthetic protectionism. A museum owes its city a reasoned selection; its responsibilities extend beyond providing a market for local artists.
The works remain decisive. In Rodin, the body becomes the site of a tension that does not settle into harmonious closure. A roughened surface engages the eye differently from polished skin. A fragment requires us to reconsider completeness. The Inner Voice can be understood as an autonomous figure precisely because its missing limbs do not cancel its movement. Artistic wholeness emerges from relationships within form. Anatomical completeness can neither guarantee nor replace it.
This is also a question of space. A sculpture organises the distances between its parts and thereby changes the space we perceive around it. Where an arm can be absent without the figure falling apart, the interval becomes active. The viewer is doing more than mentally repairing an incomplete human image. The existing form demands to be taken seriously. This offers a more exacting approach to modernism than simply admiring a historical breach of convention.
Plaster acquires particular importance here. It carries expectations of provisional status: studio, model, preparation. Yet Rodin’s use of it allows us to question those expectations. Why should artistic validity arrive only with a durable and expensive material? The assumption of an ascending order from plaster to bronze easily confuses material permanence with aesthetic completion. A collection of plaster versions can reveal how uncertain that hierarchy actually is.
With Meunier, attention shifts towards the working body. His Load Bearer offers a productive counterpoint to the popular image of The Thinker. Carrying and thinking make different demands on the body; both can be articulated through posture, weight and tension. This suggests a reading that reaches beyond the story of individual genius: modern sculpture also expands the range of experiences to which it grants artistic dignity.
The return of works long absent from public view and restored for the exhibition is therefore a substantial achievement by the Albertinum. Restoration creates the conditions for renewed judgement. A collection becomes accessible again, along with the opportunity to test established narratives against the objects themselves. This is a persuasive public responsibility.
One distinction nevertheless remains essential to criticism. The fact that history vindicated Treu’s support for Rodin does not validate every subsequent institutional decision in favour of disputed art. Opposition is no proof of quality. Neither is approval. A museum must justify its selection through the works and the precision with which it presents them. The history of earlier courage does not release it from that continuing task.
The small alabaster Thinker of my childhood belonged to a world in which Rodin’s recognition had already been secured. For me, interest in the Dresden exhibition begins where that certainty becomes open to question again. Its value lies in returning a collection to discussion. A museum proves its worth when it gives us the means to judge more closely for ourselves. Then even a long-familiar body can recover its difficulty.
Exhibition: Das große Drama. Auguste Rodin und der Streit um die Moderne
Venue: Albertinum, Staatliche Kunstsammlungen Dresden, Tzschirnerplatz 2, 01067 Dresden
Dates: 31 October 2026–22 August 2027
Curator: Astrid Nielsen
Opening hours: Tuesday–Sunday, 11 am–5 pm; the special exhibition remains open until 8 pm on Thursdays. Closed 18 January–5 February 2027.
Website: albertinum.skd.museum
© 2024 All rights reserved.
Contact:
info@dokunstmag.de
Impressum
Angaben gemäß § 5 TMG:
Esteban Velazquez v. Wilhelm
Badergraben 16 04808 Wurzen
Kontakt:
Verantwortlich für den Inhalt nach § 18 Abs.2 MstV:
+49 15776999372
Esteban Velazquez v. Wilhelm
info@dokunstmag.de
www.dokunstmag.de
