THE ART JOURNAL FOR CONTEMPORARY CULTURE, ART HISTORY, AND THOUGHT
Sophie Calle in Berlin: The Present Does Not Have the Last Word
AKTUELL
11/13/20263 min read


Sophie Calle, DDR Wappen (Palast der Republik) [GDR Emblem (Palace of the Republic)], 1996. Colour photograph and book. Hamburger Bahnhof – Nationalgalerie der Gegenwart, permanent loan from Commerzbank. © Sophie Calle. VG Bild-Kunst, Bonn 2026. Courtesy of the artist and Arndt Art Agency. Photo: Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Nationalgalerie / Thomas Bruns.
A city can remove its monuments and restore its façades. That does not give it control over its inhabitants’ memories. This is the point of departure for Sophie Calle’s exhibition Is It Better?, opening at Hamburger Bahnhof on 13 November. Marking the museum’s thirtieth anniversary, curators Sam Bardaouil and Lisa Hörstmann bring together six bodies of work spanning three decades. At its political centre is Calle’s engagement with Berlin: with dismantled GDR symbols, the vanished Palace of the Republic and the reconstructed Berlin Palace. The French artist makes clear how little an architectural decision can settle a place’s meaning. This gives the exhibition particular urgency in a capital that continually attempts to organise its history through architecture.
Born in Paris in 1953, Calle has developed an artistic practice since the late 1970s in which observation, self-imposed rules and the arrangement of texts work together. She followed strangers, investigated the traces left by hotel guests while working as a chambermaid, and constructed a portrait of an unknown man through accounts given by his acquaintances for The Address Book. Photography supplies visible evidence; text establishes relationships and possible stories between its fragments. In Detachment (1996), this method enters the terrain of political memory. Photographs of sites emptied of their monuments appear alongside recollections from passers-by and residents. The contradictions between their descriptions are part of the work’s insight. Personal memory transmits history from a particular position. It deserves serious attention without being mistaken for historical proof.
In 2012, Calle photographed the open space left after the demolition of the Palace of the Republic and asked passers-by: “Is it better?” For Is it better II, she poses the question again in 2026, this time in front of the reconstructed Berlin Palace. The passage of time changes the question’s object: what first appeared as an absence has itself become a vanished version of the city. The juxtaposition can be read as a counter-archive to history’s architectural presentation. While a reconstructed façade offers the past as a coherent image, Calle holds different experiences of the same place open alongside one another. This neither absolves the GDR retrospectively nor amounts to a blanket rejection of reconstruction. It reveals the limits of any architectural policy that seeks to establish an authoritative reading of the past through a new cityscape.
The exhibition’s curatorial logic extends from Berlin to the institutions that preserve such readings. The Ghosts of Orsay brings photographs and remnants of the abandoned Parisian railway hotel, which Calle explored around 1980, into relation with the building’s subsequent life as a museum. At Hamburger Bahnhof, itself a converted railway station, the work acquires a particular resonance: a museum also occupies a place whose earlier histories its collections cannot fully recount. Picassos in lockdown turns to the visibility of art itself. Photographed paintings, covered for protection, remain identifiable through their labels. The name asserts their significance while the image is withheld. Calle’s absences thus expose very concrete conditions of cultural authority.
Yet Calle also exercises authority over the stories she makes visible. She formulates the question, selects the statements and determines their relationship within the work. This authorship should not disappear behind the emotional appeal of multiple voices. With that reservation, the Berlin exhibition’s particular contribution becomes clear: it gives contradictory memories a form without being able to settle the dispute over history. For a museum celebrating its anniversary, this is a demanding proposition. Preservation here means keeping accessible those experiences for which the city’s currently accepted image no longer makes room.
Sophie Calle. Is It Better?
Hamburger Bahnhof – Nationalgalerie der Gegenwart
Invalidenstraße 50, 10557 Berlin
13 November 2026 – 4 April 2027
Curated by Sam Bardaouil and Lisa Hörstmann
© 2024 All rights reserved.
Contact:
info@dokunstmag.de
Impressum
Angaben gemäß § 5 TMG:
Esteban Velazquez v. Wilhelm
Badergraben 16 04808 Wurzen
Kontakt:
Verantwortlich für den Inhalt nach § 18 Abs.2 MstV:
+49 15776999372
Esteban Velazquez v. Wilhelm
info@dokunstmag.de
www.dokunstmag.de
