Van Eyck in London: The Credibility of a Face

Before the exhibition: on likeness, social visibility and what we might ask of an exceptional encounter.

DOSSIERS

Hans Struberger

11/13/20267 min read

Jan van Eyck, Portrait of a Man (Self Portrait?), 1433, oil on oak. National Gallery, London, NG222. The painting is included in the announced exhibition “Van Eyck: The Portraits”. Image: Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

The eyes seem to know us already. We return their gaze, examine the wrinkles, the flushed skin, the beginnings of a beard, and almost involuntarily take the precision of the image for a kind of personal acquaintance. With Jan van Eyck, that transition can happen very quickly. We see a face and believe we have come closer to a person. Whether we are right is another matter. It is a question I will take to London’s National Gallery when “Van Eyck: The Portraits” opens on 21 November. This essay precedes the visit. It takes the exhibition’s announced ambitions seriously and asks what ideas about people, images and historical proximity its promise contains.

The occasion is significant: nine surviving painted portraits, joined by the portrait drawing from Dresden generally accepted as van Eyck’s own work. Such a concentrated encounter allows comparisons that books and visits to separate museums can provide only imperfectly. That makes it worth deciding beforehand what we hope to see. The London announcement emphasises the vividly living presence of the sitters. My expectation goes a step further: will the exhibition also make perceptible how that presence is constructed, and what it withholds about the people represented?

Precision and its promise

The 1433 Portrait of a Man, probably a self-portrait, would offer a compelling starting point. Above the face rises the red chaperon; below it, light places a few decisive accents. The head commands a presence that is difficult to ignore. Yet the National Gallery’s own scholarly account describes interventions that complicate a straightforward celebration of faithful reproduction: altered proportions, an enlarged head, a more emphatic nose. Likeness emerges through decisions. The convincing face is the product of pictorial organisation.

This is no deception exposed centuries later. It is what the painting achieves. Van Eyck establishes differences so that we recognise relationships; he weights, concentrates and brings particular features forward. Asking whether the man looked exactly like this takes us only so far. The living sitter is unavailable for comparison. What we can examine is how the picture produces its credibility. An exhibition that approached technical skill in this way would deepen our amazement, giving it something to consider beyond the sheer quantity of visible detail.

Hans Belting’s history of face and mask supplies a theoretical horizon. It treats portraiture as a changing historical form of representation and explores the tension between the living face and its image. From that enquiry we can develop a question for London: what kind of counterpart comes into being on a painted panel? A face can address us without surrendering an inner world. The stillness of a mouth guarantees neither composure nor reserve. Anyone who immediately reads character into it supplements the painting with expectations of their own. The celebrated vitality of these portraits makes it all the more tempting to mistake such additions for knowledge.

That limit becomes particularly clear in “Léal Souvenir” of 1432. We have an individual face, a dated work and a promise of faithful remembrance. The man’s identity nevertheless remains unresolved. An exhibition should not treat this as an embarrassing gap to be filled with the most appealing conjecture available. It reveals the different reach of visibility and knowledge. A face can survive while the social connections that were obvious to its contemporaries disappear. Painting preserves an appearance; anyone seeking to recover an entire person from it asks too much.

Who was able to remain?

The museum rightly emphasises the extension of portraiture beyond dynastic elites. That shift deserves attention, but it requires precise social language. Successful merchants and craftspeople do not stand for a population that has suddenly become equally visible. Their portraits may speak of growing independence as well as rank, property and a desire for lasting recognition. The essential question is which people, under what conditions, acquired the means to transmit their particular appearance beyond their own lifetimes.

In “Form and Function of Van Eyck’s Portraiture”, Till-Holger Borchert examines the different uses of early Netherlandish likenesses. His approach guards against welcoming the autonomous modern individual in every distinctive face. Commemoration, religious use, social representation and personal relationships could overlap. That variety of functions would be fruitful territory for the London presentation. It would grant the sitters more history than the comfortable assumption that they were already, essentially, people like us.

The thought can be pursued through Jan de Leeuw, the goldsmith whom van Eyck painted holding a ring in 1436. This small object connects the painter’s visible skill with a possible reference to the sitter’s own. The ring’s precise function within the portrait requires careful consideration. Its very presence, however, complicates the idea of a person detached from social relationships. The individual gaze belongs to a material world. A sociology of portraiture begins by taking that connection seriously without reducing the face to an emblem of class.

Van Eyck himself worked within such relationships. His service to Philip the Good, his recognition at court and his patrons were conditions of his artistic position. Extracting him from that setting as a solitary discoverer of humanity would diminish the account. Nor does his court appointment, by itself, explain a painting’s particular quality. The demanding task is to bring institutional conditions and pictorial decisions into relation without making either merely an expression of the other.

Michael Baxandall’s study of the relationship between socially acquired habits of seeing and pictorial style provides a methodological corrective. His subject was fifteenth-century Italy; his findings cannot simply be transferred to Bruges. His attention to historically learned ways of looking nevertheless remains productive. What seems immediate to us need not be free of assumptions. An early viewer could read clothing, gestures, materials and lettering through different kinds of knowledge. An exhibition could help us perceive that distance rather than bridge it with a general appeal to shared humanity.

Margaret van Eyck’s portrait of 1439 introduces another form of mediation. The inscription on its frame gives her age and relationship to the painter, speaking in the first person. The sitter receives a voice, but that voice belongs to a pictorial object made by her husband. This does not diminish her presence. It makes it more complex. Who speaks here, through whom, and to what audience? Such questions permit attention to gender without inventing a modern narrative of emancipation or treating the woman in the picture as merely a function of her husband.

What a screen cannot turn over

Margaret’s portrait also shows how much an exclusively frontal reproduction leaves out. Its frame and reverse are painted to imitate marble. The picture has a physical existence extending beyond the face. The announced opportunity to view several panels from different sides in London is therefore more than an attractive addition. It could alter our understanding of the portrait: from a familiar image to a thing that was made, kept and presented in different ways.

Here is a specific expectation of the exhibition. Will the space enable us to understand that relationship, or will the front remain the sole event despite the additional views? We cannot decide before visiting. The question is legitimate nonetheless, because material construction helps shape the encounter. Painted lettering, simulated stone and a face share the same surface or physical object. To believe the face while treating the play of materials as mere decoration would separate procedures whose interaction needs examination.

The Dresden drawing offers another way of opening up the finished image. Its announced reunion with the related painting from Vienna promises insight into observation and translation. We might trace how the study of a person becomes a sustained pictorial form. For me, this would be a substantial gain: the master would become visible through his decisions. Such attention to work and revision can sharpen admiration without turning the painting into a demonstration of technical findings.

Our faces, their distance

Why should this matter particularly now? Because the production of credible faces runs through daily life. An edited profile photograph, biometric identification and a synthetically generated face serve different purposes. They should not be collapsed into a single phenomenon. Together, however, they make a distinction urgent for which van Eyck’s portraits open a historical space of reflection: appearance, identification and knowledge of a person are different achievements. A convincing image guarantees none of them automatically.

This connection to the present is a question posed by today’s viewer. It attributes no foresight to the painter. Van Eyck did not need to anticipate our imaging technologies to work on problems whose later forms concern us. Nor must his works confirm our present. Their historical distance can unsettle our habits precisely because the sitters cannot be translated entirely into contemporary ideas of identity and self-presentation.

We might imagine how astonished van Eyck would have been by our technical capabilities. As a thought experiment, this is appealing; as a measure of quality, it gets us little distance. If we made his importance depend entirely on accuracy of reproduction, we would subject it to devices performing different tasks by different means. What matters is how this particular painting organises attention and gives duration to an appearance. Greater resolution does not settle that question. It can show us more while leaving us with the same uncertainty about the person.

Admiration for the old masters should therefore resist retreating into a supposedly lost perfection of craftsmanship. That would turn them into a comfortable alternative world in which the disturbances of contemporary images could be avoided. A more interesting encounter would shake our confidence in seeing. For that to happen, van Eyck’s skill would have to become accessible in its historical particularity. The past does not acquire significance only when we acknowledge it as an earlier version of ourselves.

The National Gallery will help construct this encounter. Its announced, unrepeatable gathering of the works already generates a particular expectation. Such rarity has practical reasons in the dispersal and vulnerability of the surviving objects; its public presentation also confers cultural authority on the museum. This is no grounds for suspicion of the exhibition. It establishes a demand: an exceptional gathering should enable comparisons and insights beyond the prestige of the assembled names. The institution has itself set out a scholarly ambition involving materials, frames and inscriptions. Its presentation can be assessed against that ambition.

I will visit this exhibition with anticipation. Its announcement gives ample reason for high expectations and ample material with which to make those expectations precise. Whether the encounter supports the arguments developed here or productively contradicts them remains open. DOKUNST will return to these questions after the visit. For now, we should welcome the fact that these pictures are coming together: we will have the opportunity to examine their differences in the originals. The faces will continue to look at us. What matters will be whether we look long enough to lose our first certainty about them.

Van Eyck: The Portraits
National Gallery, Trafalgar Square, London WC2N 5DN
21 November 2026 – 11 April 2027

© 2024 All rights reserved.

Contact:

info@dokunstmag.de

Impressum

Angaben gemäß § 5 TMG:

Esteban Velazquez v. Wilhelm

Badergraben 16 04808 Wurzen

Kontakt:

Verantwortlich für den Inhalt nach § 18 Abs.2 MstV:

+49 15776999372

Esteban Velazquez v. Wilhelm

info@dokunstmag.de

www.dokunstmag.de

Badergraben 16 04808 Wurzen